JustFoodForDogs · Week one · Sept 2026
Close the two real leaks, touch nothing that's already working.
Seven days: confirm before spend, ship the two missing angles, then read the result against a decision rule written down in advance.



1 · The situation this plan starts from
Pulled live from Meta's Ad Library on 2026-09-08: the active paid account is large and genuinely diversified — direct-brand creative, a city-by-city local-affiliate/creator network, and co-branded retail-partner ads with Petco, Chewy and Pet Food Express. This is not an under-invested account. Two real, specific leaks showed up in the same pass.
A stranger owns your comparison moment
"The Customer Digest" names JustFoodForDogs directly in a live paid ad and routes the click to its own affiliate page instead of justfoodfordogs.com.
Your newest news isn't in any ad
Neither Targeted Nutrition (March 2026) nor the new CEO, Michael Meyer (May 2026), appears in any ad copy pulled in this check.
2 · Days 1–2 — confirm before anything touches spend
- Get real access: the Meta ad account, the Ordergroove subscription dashboard (new as of May 2026), and whatever attribution/analytics exist — none of this plan can be read without it.
- Confirm exact current per-dog pricing across the three product tiers in the landing page's offer block — JFFD prices by weight/recipe via its own calculator, not a fixed SKU.
- Confirm the current offer's terms and end date ("50% off 1st Autoship and 5% off future orders"), and what replaces it when it lapses.
- Confirm paid-media usage of customer reviews and dog photos — Rocky's story (Ad 15) is published on justfoodfordogs.com; running it in paid still needs Danielle & Kenny's OK.
- Legal/brand review of Ad 07 ("Text From the Vet") — labeled a dramatization on the creative; confirm that's enough for JFFD's own standards.
3 · Days 3–5 — close the two real leaks, don't touch what's working
Two concrete moves, both grounded in gaps the audit actually found — not a replacement for the existing affiliate/retail-partner program, which is real, working distribution.
MOVE 01Ship Targeted Nutrition into paid
Ad 05, "Four Bowls, Four Problems." JFFD's newest, most differentiated product news, still absent from every ad pulled. Already built from existing packaging photography — fast to test.
MOVE 02Run one honest comparison ad of JFFD's own
Ad 09 ("Kibble vs. Kitchen") or Ad 02 ("The Label Nobody Reads"), small budget, aimed at the "best fresh dog food" moment The Customer Digest currently wins by default. No competitor named or shown.
Both moves run additively alongside the existing affiliate network and retail-partner ads.
4 · Days 6–7 — read it honestly, decide
With only a few days of spend this isn't a full CAC decision — it's a smaller, honest signal: does either new angle get attention against the account's existing baseline, and does the comparison ad measurably dent the demand-capture leak.
The decision rule, set now, before any result exists
Keep going — worth a real test
If the Targeted Nutrition ad's click-through rate or cost-per-click clearly beats the account's existing baseline once real access exists, or the comparison ad shows any measurable dent in branded-search traffic going to The Customer Digest's affiliate page.
Stop — try a different execution, not a bigger budget
If either angle burns spend with negligible clicks. That's a creative-execution problem, not evidence the idea is wrong — Ads 01, 04 and 08 are more executions of the transparency/proof angle, and 11, 12 and 14 are lighter-touch humor versions to try first.
No CAC target gets set this week. A target set before a real baseline exists is a guess dressed up as a plan — the baseline comes first, then the target.
5 · What this week deliberately does not do
- It does not touch the affiliate/creator network or the retail-partner ads carrying real volume.
- It does not run Ad 15 (Rocky's review) in paid until the customers confirm usage, or Ad 07 until brand review signs off on the dramatization label.
- It does not promise a 90-day CAC number, a scaled budget, or a second ad channel. Those come after real access and a real first read.